During a recent speech the head of the Korean Labor & Employment Law Team and I gave to the American Chamber of Commerce in Korea, a few interesting topics came up that seemed to be of particular interest to participants.
For the Power Point of the presentation click HERE.
Factors Courts use to Determine if an Individual is an Employee and Thus Obligated to Provide Severance and Employment Security etc. Under the Korea Labor Standards Act (LSA).
These following factors are used by the Korean Supreme Court to determine if one is an “employee” under the Korean LSA. The factors are not weighted equally by courts in Korea.
Please note that these factors are not weighted equally by courts and all factors are not required to be met for an independent contractor to be deemed an employee under the LSA. An answer in the affirmative to anyone one of the factors increases the risk to the employer.
- Does company have decision making power over the content of work of the individual?
- Are company work rules applied to the individual?
- Does company have considerable control over the work processes of the individual?
- Does company set the time and date and other specifics of work?
- Does company own the work assets?
- Can individuals use a third party to replace the work of the individual?
- Does individual have business risks associated with work with company?
- Are earnings based on work – not success?
- Does individual near exclusively depend on the work from the company?
- Is the work with the company continuous, thus, not temporary?
- Is the individual deemed an employee under the Social Security System?
The court may also consider the relevant social and economic situation between the employer and the independent contractor.
After a very lively discussion on these factors and the state of independent contractors under Korean Law, we briefly explained the obligations of employers to employees. The two most noteworthy obligations discussed were:
Obligations to Employees Under the Labor Standards Act
A justifiable reason can be either a fault attributable to the employee or an “urgent managerial necessity.” For layoffs based on urgent managerial necessity, an employer must:
- Implement a “rational and fair” criteria in choosing the persons to layoff;
- Give 50 days notice to the union or representative prior to layoff;
- Give 30 days notice (or payment in lieu of notice);
- Provide three years of preferential rehiring;
- Provide written and specific notice of what the “urgent managerial necessity” is. (the near impossible standard for the employer to meet –the “bankruptcy avoidance test” has been changed in recent years to the more easily capable of meeting “rational business” test.)
For dismissals based on cause, multiple notices should be given to the employee unless the violation is a serious violation of law.
The LSA states that an employer should provide an employee with 30 days of compensation for each year of service to the company. The rate for this compensation should be based on the average of the last three months of employment. This payment should be made within 14 days of retirement.
Sean Hayes may be contacted at: [email protected] Sean is co-chair of the Korea Practice Team at IPG Legal. He is the first non-Korean attorney to have worked for the Korean court system (Constitutional Court of Korea) and one of the first non-Koreans to be a regular member of a Korean law faculty. Sean is ranked, for Korea, as one of only two non-Korean lawyers as a Top Attorney by AsiaLaw. Sean is known for his proactive New York-style street-market advice and his aggressive and non-conflicted advocacy. Sean works with some of the leading retired judges, prosecutors and former government officials working in Korea.
Sean’s profile may be found at: Sean C. Hayes
- Korean Independent Contractor Risks: Korean Labor Standards Act Basics
- Terminate/Layoff an Employee in Korea: Terminating an Employee in Korea
- Non-Registered Company Director (Executive Director/Senior Managerial Worker) in Korea deemed Employee under Korean Labor & Employment Law
- Must I grant Male Employees Maternity/Paternity Leave in Korea?: Korean Labor/Employment Law Updates
- Non-Compete Clauses in Employment Agreements in Korea
- Non-Compete Restrictive Covenant in Employment Contracts in Korea
- Termination after Childcare Leave in Korea: Childcare Leave Law in Korea
- “Cause” Needed to Terminate During Probationary Period in Korea?
- Part-time Worker Annual Paid Leave Obligations under the Korean Labor Standards Act
- Can you Revise Employment Rules in Korea without the Agreement of Employees?