A recent amendment of the Korean Civil Procedure Act added Article 217-2. The Amendment has codified a holding by the Seoul Central District Court and other Korean courts noting, in part, that Korean courts may refuse to “recognize foreign damage awards that clearly exceed amounts considered reasonable in Korea in violation of good morals and the social order of Korea”(99 KaHap 14496, S. Cent. Distr. Court, 10/20/2000).
The Amendment allows courts, in Korea, the power to not recognize a damage award that the court’s perceives as “excessive.” This standard-less “standard” leaves much wiggle room for Korean courts.
A typical situation is a case where an American importer sues a Korean conglomerate in a U.S. court and damages are awarded to the U.S. company. The American importer, then, attempts to enforce the judgment in Korea.
There is a simple way to avoid the risk of your judgment not being enforced in Korea. Don’t require yourself to have a need to enforce your judgment in Korea.
Be smart – sign the agreement, not, with a Korean conglomerate’s Korean HQ, but with the American subsidiary of the Korean conglomerate if, inter alia, the subsidiary is capitalized and has assets to attach. Most Korean companies have substantial assets tucked away in Hong Kong, U.S. and European companies.
Please have an attorney with significant experience with enforcing judgments against Korean conglomerates review your agreement. Signing an agreement with a subsidiary poses, potentially, other risks.
The reality is, with this amendment and a few noted cases, a foreign judgment may not be fully enforced in Korea. Thus, put strategy to work for you. Also, remember it is better, in most cases, to not work and not be paid than to work and not be paid.
Sean Hayes may be contacted at: SeanHayes@ipglegal.com.
Sean Hayes is co-chair of the Korea Practice Team at IPG Legal.
He is the first non-Korean attorney to have worked for the Korean court system (Constitutional Court of Korea) and one of the first non-Koreans to be a regular member of a Korean law faculty. Sean is ranked, for Korea, as one of only two non-Korean lawyers as a Top Attorney by AsiaLaw.
- Enforcement of Arbitral Awards in Korean Courts
- Does a Korean court have the power to issue a preliminary attachment on Korean assets stemming from a foreign court claim?
- Starting a Company in Korea: Establishing a Foreign Capital-Invested Korean Company, Branch or Liaison Office
- Execution/Enforcement of American, European & other Nation Court Judgments in Korean Courts
- Non-Compete Restrictive Covenant in Employment Contracts in Korea
- Contracts Necessary for Doing Business with a Korean Company?