Korean Supreme Court Holds Landlord Liable for Renting Out Home After Refusing Lease Renewal

A Korean landlord who refuses to renew a residential lease because they intend to live in the property may owe damages if they later rent it to someone else. Moving in temporarily does not automatically protect the landlord from liability.

In a September 10, 2026 decision, Korea’s Supreme Court upheld an award of approximately KRW 30.8 million to a tenant whose landlord rejected renewal on “personal occupancy grounds.” The landlord’s subsequent need to repay other tenants’ deposits did not excuse the decision to rent the apartment out again (Supreme Court Decision 2026Da203203).

advertisements covering buildings on street corner in seoul

Supreme Court of Korea Precedent: Liability of Landlord for Renting Out Home After Refusing Lease Renewal

The dispute concerned an apartment in Seoul’s Seodaemun District. The tenant signed a jeonse lease (lump sum lease payment) in July 2020, providing a KRW 660 million deposit for a term running from September 2020 to September 2022.

In May 2022, the landlord informed the tenant to vacate the unit because the landlord intended to occupy the apartment. The tenant requested another two years, but the landlord refused. The tenant moved out.

The landlord, who had been overseas, registered an address at the apartment in September 2022 and returned to Korea in February 2023. After living there for approximately 14 months, the landlord rented it to another tenant in April 2024 for a KRW 820 million deposit. Had the landlord granted a renewal, the original tenant’s lease would have continued until September 2024.

The landlord argued that six tenants at another property had simultaneously requested the return of deposits totaling approximately KRW 690 million. The landlord claimed that renting out the apartment again was necessary to meet those repayment obligations.

The first-level trial court accepted the argument and dismissed the claim. The appellate court reversed, finding that the deposit repayment obligations were foreseeable and that the landlord had other ways to raise the money. The Korean Supreme Court upheld that decision.

Under Article 6-3(5) of Korea’s Housing Lease Protection Act, a landlord who refuses renewal on personal occupancy grounds is liable if, without justifiable grounds, the property is rented to a third party before the renewal period would have expired.

The Supreme Court of Korea explained that the landlord must prove both that the circumstances were “unforeseeable when renewal was refused and that those circumstances made renting to a third party unavoidable.” The landlord failed to establish those requirements. The Court noted that an urgent need for money was insufficient on these facts.

The practical significance is that actual occupancy does not end the inquiry. Here, the landlord lived in the apartment for approximately 14 months. Liability still arose from renting it out during the period the original tenant would have been entitled to occupy it. A tenant’s claim therefore need not depend solely on proving that the landlord’s original promise to move in was false.

The Act also provides a specific damages calculation. Unless the parties agreed on damages when renewal was refused, Article 6-3(6) provides for the greater of:

  • Three months of the converted monthly rent applicable when renewal was refused.
  • Twenty-four months of the difference between the new tenant’s converted monthly rent and the converted monthly rent at the time of refusal.
  • The tenant’s actual loss caused by the refusal.

Converted monthly rent includes the deposit converted under a statutory formula. These provisions therefore apply to jeonse leases even where no monthly rent is paid.

Tenants should preserve their renewal request, the landlord’s response, the original lease, evidence of the later tenancy, and records supporting their losses. Landlords should assess foreseeable deposit repayments before refusing renewal and document any later circumstances said to make renting the property out unavoidable.

For additional articles in Korean Real Estate & Landlord-Tenant Law, please see: IPG Legal’s Korean Real Estate Law Archive. To schedule a call with an attorney, please: Contact Us.


Discover more from The Korean Law Blog by IPG Legal Law Firm

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply